Giddens compares the then current state of our
society between the description of postmodernity and radicalized modernity. He
uses some of Max Weber’s ideas in that as society advances “the bonds of
rationality are drawn tighter and tighter, imprisoning us in a featureless cage
of bureaucratic routine.” (p.367). I understand this because I can see the same
thing happen as you grow up and advance through school. As a young kid you’re
running wild but as you get older and move up in school; cliques and crowds and
in groups form and there’s less individuality. Which actually while just
writing that, helped me understand the next part of the reading I didn’t understand.
Giddens said that Weber’s characterization of bureaucracy is inadequate and
that “Rather than tending inevitably towards rigidity, organizations produce
areas of autonomy and spontaneity – which are often less easy to achieve in
smaller groups.” (p.368). I didn’t get this because I figured if you’re in a
smaller group than it would be easier to keep tabs on each other. Using the same
example of kids in school, for me I saw that when people found their smaller segregated
groups that they were comfortable with, they could be more themselves because
they felt safe around the ones they were with. I know my example isn’t a
perfect match to what he’s talking about but it helps me relate. An uncommon
relationship he mentioned later on was the one between intimacy and abstract
systems, specifically “Money, for example, can be spent to purchase the expert
services of a psychologist who guides the individual in an exploration of the
inner universe of the intimate and the personal.” (p.369) and he brings this up
in the mention of how we are encouraged more and more in a modernized society
to exchange intimacy for impersonality.
I thought this was a very interesting sumblog. I can totally agree that when kids are younger they do have so much more individuality. I can see the difference from when I go on field trips with my kindergartner and when I go with my fifth grader. Already by fifth grade kids are looking at each other to see if they are doing things right.
ReplyDelete